CONSUMABLES
I stick 5 (one red, one yellow, one green, one blue, one violet) under seats every night. These are likely good for a couple shows but occasionally folks will rip them open like it’s Christmas - so nice to have fresh ones ready to go. Also this is what I use to stick them. Typically a roll is good for a week of shows.
I use two of these Yellow balloons per show. You can find cheaper ones as long as they’re yellow.
I also blow up other balloons - I’ve used these but if you find cheaper ones that’s fine too. They just have to be various colors.
Just your standard mini pencil - no real preference here but all audience members should get one when entering.
Paper
Print one for each audience member each night. Ideally on a 14pt cardstock.
Newspaper
Just a few newspapers per week to repair a prop that gets used every night. The newspaper is backing for a “dart board” and I use the parts of the newspaper with dense copy/words to fill the dart board with words (i.e. I don’t use papers that have lots of ads/images).